Before last year, Whitney McGuire hadn’t seriously considered stashing an emergency survival kit in her home. But as 2020’s record-breaking fire season descended on the West Coast, the attorney, sustainability strategistA mother who lives in Brooklyn was struck by the thought of what she might need to do to prepare for a climate-related disaster.
“I was feeling an incredible amount of anxiety about everything, and I wanted to feel like I had some agency in whatever the apocalypse is going to look like for me,” she said.
Ms. McGuire (35), started shopping online for supplies. She then discovered the growing world of fashionable emergency preparedness brands.
Aaron Levy, director at FEMA’s individual and community preparedness division, recent surveys indicate that the country is in the middle of “a tidal wave of culture change” when it comes to disaster prepping.
“I think we’re starting to see a shift in the assumption that ‘this can’t happen where I live,’” said Mr. Levy.
FEMA and other nonprofit organizations like the Red Cross have been trying to prepare people for disasters for a long time. But the rise of for profit companies in this space shows just how important that shift is.
This category includes companies that cater to survivalists as well as ex-military personnel. Uncharted Supply Co.This company sells streamlined backpacks that include small shovels and stormproof matches, as well as water filters. My Medic(which sells first aid supplies in large quantities packaged in utilitarian bags). But as far as Ms. McGuire was concerned, these brands target “outdoorsy, cis white men,” with marketing materials that often feature muscular white guys wearing flannel shirts in the forest.
There has been a new wave in emergency preparation companies that cater to a style-conscious clientele. They are, first and foremost, PreppiGoop-approved brand, sells disaster supplies and minimalist backpacks. Judy, which has used celebrities like Chrissy Teigen, Chrissy Kardashians, and TikTok sensation Addison Rae as ambassadors for its portable generators.
Indeed, it was Judy’s approachable branding that caught Ms. McGuire’s eye a year after she first tried to build an emergency kit, and was overwhelmed with so much dread she abandoned a half-full shopping cart.
“It looks almost like a yogurt brand or something,” Ms. McGuire said after seeing a Judy ad on Instagram. “It’s very friendly, and it’s kind of making the end of the world feel a little more colorful.”
That’s by design. Simon Huck, founder of celebrity PR firm Command Entertainment Group, founded the company. a close friend of Kim KardashianJosh Udashkin, who is best known for starting a buzzy, but short-lived, luggage company. RadenJudy is here to provide emergency kits in a way that is more welcoming than intimidating.
“Emergency preparedness needed a rebrand,” Mr. Huck said. “It can be really scary, and I think a lot of folks shut down when they hear about it. So our mission has been: How can we get people to care?”
Judy’s founders turned to Red Antler, the agency responsible for creating brand identities for Allbirds and Casper, for help in making what Mr. Huck calls the “least sexy category” more appealing.
Ada Mayer (creative director of Red Antler), designed their approach. It focused on tapping positive emotions and not exploiting the fear that often comes with emergency prep. Judy never shows the “after” shots of homes that have been destroyed by wildfires or flooding, only the “before” images depicting happy families occupying pre-disaster living rooms.
The brand’s signature orange calls to mind traffic cones, signaling caution without ringing the mental alarm bells associated with what Ms. Mayer calls “medical red.” And the brand’s logo features a chunky typeface that she describes as simultaneously “bold and steady” and also “a little bit friendly and disarming.”
“The goal was to create something pragmatic, but also very accessible,” Ms. Mayer said. “We took a potentially frightening and off-putting subject matter and made it more inviting.”
Judy launched in January 2020 and has sold more than 25,000 disaster kits. She also has nearly 60,000 followers. on its meme-strewn Instagram page45,000 subscribers signed up for the text-message program that provides emergency preparation information. Mr. Huck indicated that the business is on track towards doubling its monthly growth in 2021.
Some people seem to be finding Judy’s emergency prep resources before they find FEMA’s, as evidenced by Judy’s FAQ page, which includes the question, “Do I contact you if disaster strikes and I need help?” (The answer, for the record, is no: Judy is “not a real time alerting authority.”)
According to Antony Loewenstein, journalist and author of “Disaster Capitalism: Making A Killing Out Of Catastrophe,” that’s just one of the potential downsides of brand-led responses to disaster.
The other has to do with these brands’ relationships to environmental politics. While Mr. Huck recognizes the importance of this role, climate crisis plays in increasing weather-related calamities, Judy’s website and social media are intentionally devoid of the term “climate change” lest it alienate potential customers who deem it “too politicized” — despite the fact that Americans who think global warming is happening outnumber those who don’t by more than six to one. Judy doesn’t publish anything about the environmental impacts of manufacturing its products, either.
As far as Mr. Loewenstein is concerned, this is “avoiding the elephant in the room.”
“You have increasing numbers of companies saying, ‘we can assist you to address what everyone knows is a growing climate crisis.’ But there’s no openness about why this is happening,” Mr. Loewenstein said. “They should be asking, ‘Am I, as a corporation, complicit, in supply chains and elsewhere?’”
Dr. Samantha Montano, assistant professor of emergency management at Massachusetts Maritime Academy and author of “Disasterology,”Other problems are seen with market-led responses in the face of disaster. “This individualistic approach runs into limitations,” she said. “Particularly the conceptualization of preparedness as this consumeristic process where somebody can just go out and buy a bunch of stuff, and then be fine.”
What she would like to see instead is a greater focus on holistic disaster preparation, with a particular emphasis on the communities that can’t afford to drop between $195 and $995 on a Kardashian-approved emergency kit.
Mr. Huck isn’t interested in branding brands like his as being seen as opportunistic. He compares their offerings to those of an alarm company or insurance company. And if approachable branding like Judy’s can help “make emergency preparedness part of the zeitgeist, where people can actually talk about it and don’t feel turned off,” he said, he’ll feel like he has accomplished part of his goal.
For Ms. McGuire, the price of Judy products ended up feeling prohibitive, as did what she perceived to be a lack of interest on the brand’s part in serving the working class people that tend to most need disaster relief. She’s still interested in emergency readiness for her own family, but she’s starting with prep that doesn’t cost anything, like gathering important documents in easy-to-grab, waterproof containers.
Even Mr. Huck can see the wisdom.
“The number one thing you can do to save lives is make an emergency plan, more so than actually having a physical product,” he said.