New York City and Our Environment Will Be Hurt by a Crypto Mining Ban

New York has been a driving force in technological and economic development and has contributed to the success and growth of the United States. Many in the state, including Eric Adams, New York City Mayor, are now Imagine New York as the center of the cryptocurrency industry.” Unfortunately, it appears that the memo hasnt yet reached Albany, as state legislators are gearing up this week to pass a two-year moratorium on crypto mining, which will drive the nascent industry out of the state and potentially worsen current carbon emissions.

New Yorkers across the state are being promised substantial investments and well-paying job opportunities in crypto. Instead of creating a regulatory environment that fosters the industry, legislators seem to be looking to eliminate it.

After a close vote on Monday that passed the bill through Committee, state legislators in the Assembly will soon vote for legislation that would place a 2-year moratorium on the bill. MoratoriumNew York State’s proof of work crypto mining projects. Legislation like this sends a negative signal to crypto entrepreneurs, and would have a chilling impact on the industry’s growth.

It is a permanent ban on all forms of mining in the state. Investors and entrepreneurs are unlikely to wait for two years in the hope that lawmakers will finally get on board with crypto. New York seems determined create as many barriers to entry to crypto as it can, as more states open up their doors to the industry.

The bill’s proponents claim that crypto mining projects, especially those operating under the proof of work method, are damaging the environment, using too much energy, and are increasing energy prices. While we agree with their desire to reduce carbon emissions and bring energy costs under control, it would be a mistake to push crypto mining from New York, which boasts some the nation’s strictest carbon emissions standards.

Even if New York bans crypto mining, proof of work mining will not be banned in the United States. These operations will instead be relocated to other states, creating high-paying jobs in other states, and allowing these projects under less stringent environmental regulations than they would in New York.

This decision will hinder the New York crypto sector’s progress, could lead to increased carbon emissions, and could harm communities that have built jobs around the industry. Co-locating with renewable projects in areas that are not affected by transmission issues could be a way for crypto mining to accelerate the transition from fossil fuels in New York.

Legislators need to look at the real-world benefits of this innovation holistically. Legislation is also being considered for the study of the industry’s impact on New York. Multiple bills could empower state agencies to study and implement a taskforce. Authors of the mining ban even sponsor legislation to study crypto. Why ban an industry without understanding it?

New York has been a beacon of economic growth and innovation for many years. We can help open the door to crypto adoption today and make it a global leader. Albany’s misguided legislation may impede this progress, ceding New York’s supremacy to other states and countries. 

This is a crucial moment in our history. Let us make the right choices.

Every evening, you will receive the latest crypto news and insights in your email. Subscribe to Blockworks free newsletter now.