Vladimir Putin sought to convince some of Italy’s most prominent businessmen to “feel as comfortable as possible” about the Russian market during a videoconference on Wednesday that studiously avoided mention of the topic in most minds: the 106,000 troops Russia’s president has stationed around Ukraine.
Business leaders including the CEOs of banking group UniCredit, tyre manufacturer Pirelli and state-owned utility Enel discussed Moscow’s climate change ambitions, economic reforms and business opportunities as part of an event organised by the Italian-Russian chamber of commerce, according to participants.
The meeting went ahead despite the office of prime minister Mario Draghi’s plea on Tuesday evening to postpone it, said a government official. According to four people involved in the discussions, Vincenzo Trani (head of the Italy-Russia chamber for commerce) insisted that it was too late for it to be rescheduled. Trani’s spokesperson was not immediately available for comment.
The encounter underlines the Kremlin’s efforts to sway the European business elite as the US and Europe debate a new package of sanctions in case Putin invades Ukraine. After its 2014 annexation, the US warned Moscow that it is planning another military attack.
Geopolitical tensions between Moscow and the EU and the US were not discussed at the meeting but one participant said there was “a general feeling of embarrassment”. Another said that while the meeting was “badly timed”, backing out at the last minute would have exposed them to retaliation since they had all been doing business in Russia for years.
Francesco Starace, chief executive at Enel, suggested Russia lower its carbon emissions targets, according to several participants who spoke anonymously. The ministers of energy and transport, finance, finance and industry, as well as top business leaders, were present at the Russian side. Enel declined comment.
Other Italian state-controlled companies — including oil company Eni, oil service group Saipem and gas transport company Snam — planned to attend the meeting but pulled out on Tuesday.
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov denied any Italian executives had dropped out under pressure from Draghi’s government, saying the changes were because of illness and scheduling conflicts.
Other participants including UniCredit chief Andrea Orcel, Pirelli chief Marco Tronchetti Provera and Generali chair Gabriele Galateri di Genola, discussed their companies’ presence in Russia.
During the initial part of the meeting, which was televised, Putin said Russia wanted Italian business “to feel as comfortable as possible about the Russian market”. He stressed that Italy, one of Europe’s largest importers of Russian gas, had been able to buy gas supplies “far below spot market prices that grew significantly due to the cold winter and a supply glut” thanks to long-term contracts with Kremlin monopoly Gazprom.
This meeting had “nothing to do with the current situation or any sanctions,” Peskov said before the encounter. “Life goes on, business’ interests are not going anywhere, they have a presence on the Russian market [ . . .] As long as they’re making money in Russia, they’re interested in having this conversation.”
The date of the event was agreed in November with the knowledge of Italy’s foreign ministry. Putin holds business meetings with European business executives occasionally. He met French executives last year and German business leaders in 2019, according to the Kremlin’s website.
Officials from Italy insist that the meeting was a private affair. The Italian-Russian business committee which helped organize it was established by Luigi Di Maio, foreign minister.
“This would have been no news at a different time. Clearly for the Italian government not to call this off at such a sensitive time was a mistake,” said a chief executive, who nevertheless attended.